Force charge without my knowledge
Hi all, I had solar panels and a fox h1g2 inverter and fox ep12 battery installed around 6 weeks ago, but over the last 2 days I've noticed it has been force charging itself overnight whilst set to self use mode. My force charge schedule has only 1 timeslot set up and that is 2am to 5am, to reach 40% Soc, but that is currently toggled to the off position. My battery charged itself from 10% to 26% yesterday morning around 7am, then charged itself to 40% at around midnight, and charged again to 45% at 4am. After the first battery charge I set my pre heater to 4° as it has got cold recently. (down to 0 - minus 1 or 2 °)
I thought this would eliminate the charging itself issue, but it hasn't.
I'm currently on a fixed rate tariff whilst I wait for my DNO letter to arrive, thats why my battery is down at 10% Soc a lot of the time.
Can anyone offer some advice please?
Lee
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Here is a long read, viewtopic.php?p=6448#p6448 I was waiting for the first cold snap to see a post :lol:

In short, the battery BMS will do a maintenance charge IIRC below 5°C or some low temp like that to protect the cells. This will charge no matter what work mode you are set to.

I suggest you increase that start temperature for the heater to 9°C and end at 15°C (you can adjust those start end points of course) those values worked best for me, as the battery charge AND discharge rate changes with certain temperature brackets, so you want to keep it in the goldilocks zone.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
It’s usually a strong indicator that the lowest cell in your battery is very cold and the BMS will start a slow maintenance charge to raise the temperature. It’s both temperature and SoC dependent so will not do it at higher charge levels. Once you have your low tariff, force charging at night will warm it up and the higher state of charge should avoid the issue.

I don’t use battery warmup myself, but I believe that most people set the temperature to around 9C as at 4C it’s getting too close to the battery discharge shutting down which at low soc’s will be what’s doing the bump charge.

EDIT : @MB, sorry you just beat me to it ;)
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Well I'm glad I'm not the only one, seems one of the cells ("Min. Cell Temp") was below some threshold at some point (it's barely above 4.1C now at 10 AM). The inverter temperature hit a low of 3.6C at 2 AM, but Battery temperature remained above 13C. So I assumed it had something to do with temperature.

It started charging at 2 AM until 4, then again at 7 AM until 8 AM when the PV started to pick up the early morning sun.

I will enable the battery heating and set the time period to charge during lowest cost period in the night and keep an eye on it. It would be useful if the running state or some other status explained why it forced charging, the inverter status remain as `on-line` and the running state was `163: on-grid`.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
WelshProgrammer wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:15 am I will enable the battery heating and set the time period to charge during lowest cost period in the night and keep an eye on it. It would be useful if the running state or some other status explained why it forced charging, the inverter status remain as `on-line` and the running state was `163: on-grid`.
The on-line status doesn’t show it, but if you track the ‘Max Bat Charge (or Discharge) Current’ you’ll likely see the effects of temperature as the BMS throttles the charge.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Screenshot from 2026-11-13 10-42-37.png
I'll try to find some way of correlating these in HA. Shame the FoxESS HA doesn't expose the Min Cell Temp (or at least it doesn't in my setup). That would probably be the key in tracking this.

I'll dig in the API and see if it's returned, just not extracted.

Cheers, WP.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
WelshProgrammer wrote: ↑Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:44 am Screenshot from 2026-11-13 10-42-37.png

I'll try to find some way of correlating these in HA. Shame the FoxESS HA doesn't expose the Min Cell Temp (or at least it doesn't in my setup). That would probably be the key in tracking this.

I'll dig in the API and see if it's returned, just not extracted.

Cheers, WP.
Sadly it isn’t, but you can get them via modbus if you want to change your implementation, Fox said they would provide them but then decided against it (I suspect the BMS algorithm may be a bit flaky on some battery firmware), they provided the Max Bat sensors instead as a concession.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
I've found minimum cell temperature on my Evo is exposed in register 37618, under BMS cell temp low

I had to add my model manually to entity description.py under that. Try it on read register first to validate.
7.36kWp solar array made of 16x Jinko Tiger Neo 460w panels. 8 ESE, 8 WNW facing, Fox EVO 10kWh with 10kW inverter. Installed April 2026. Running ModBus via Elfin EW11A, learning Home Assistant
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Hi,
Thank you for your responses, I will change my heater settings to 9° minimum.
I contacted my installer , who then contacted Fox, and they did a firmware update on the inverter, but that does not seem to have fixed it. My battery self charged at 31% upto 45%, at 00.20 and then charged again at 05.30 from 33% to 41%.
Installer said to contact them again if it continues. So, an email to them is incoming....
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
I would hold off that email Lee, and change the temperature first (like you mentioned to min 9°C) and see if that sorts the emergency charges.

If you have cheap overnight tariff, you can program those times in, and overnight is when it is typically the coldest. I would also sort some insulation out too, as this is better in the longer term.

Good luck.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Morning all,
I did as advised and changed my warm up temps to 9° and 15°, but yet again my battery self charged at 4am from 28% to 44%. So I checked my batt cell temp and it showed around 3° at the time it self charged.
So, I went back into the warm up settings and discovered that my 3 timeslots for grid charging were toggled off. As soon as I edited one of the timeslots to 00.00 -23.59, and toggled it on, the heating symbol showed around my cell temp and was up at 15° within 15 mins or so.
So, I think my troubles are over. A simple case of turning a timeslot on to enable battery heating.
Many thanks for your help, it is very much appreciated for a complete solar novice.
When I finally get my DNO and look to switch tariff, is octopus flux a decent option? My installation was by an independent company, so I don't think I qualify for intelligent flux. And, what overnight Soc is a good starting point for November/December weather in Manchester Uk. I don't want to fill the battery then miss out on any free pv elecy.
Again, any help is appreciated
Thanks,
Lee
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
In theory, if you have enough PV power, then it *should* heat from that energy. That being said, sometime it is thick as mince, mine wouldn't show heating at all when I was testing again the other night. So I turned it off again, and I checked 20mins or so later, and it had increased by over a degree :shock:

So in your case, setting a 24hr charge from grid, would allow it to charge in the absence of PV energy.

The tariff choice can vary, what sort of daily consumption do you have in kWh?

As you have an EP12, you should have about 10.37kWh available to you from new, if you are using say around 12-15kWh, then Octopus Go could be a good import tariff (l don't think they check for EV proof still) If your daily power use figures are above 20kWh, then you might be better with Octopus Cosy, so you can charge 3x per day for half price.

Export, I just use the flat 12p rate and forget about it, you could make more with other choices maybe, but I don't want to fret about it too much.

What you should do look into is Axle Energy, as they pay currently £1 per kWh during 'events' with a min payment of £10 pcm. You will also get your 12p flat rate on top if you pair with flat rate outgoing Octopus. With Cosy tariff, I can charge up the battery to 100% just before 16:00 for ~15p kWh, then if an Axle event is on for that evening, sell that out at £1.12 kWh. If you need to buy back some electric before the next cheap rate (22:00) then it's around 30p kWh (so you still make a profit)

Take a look here (yes that's a cheeky referral code, you get £25 sign on bonus as would I)
https://vpp.axle.energy/landing?ref=R-ZIFGMMKO
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
We use approx 11 kw - 17 kw, the higher days are usually weekends or the mrs is going washing machine mental.
I don't have an EV or heatpump as of yet. So I don't think I'd qualify for cosy tariff, which is annoying, cos I like the multiple cheap windows that offers.
The topping up and then exporting through Axle sounds like a great idea. Would Axle and flux work together? That could be around £1.30 ish per kw if so.
Does continually filling and draining the battery make it less efficient over the years? Bit of a false economy if I'm having to replace the battery several years earlier than expected.

Thanks for your continued help @MaterialBarracuda48, I might know what I'm doing soon...

Lee
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Cosy don't check for proof, it's a literal tick the box exercise, it might be same for Octopus Go also. Given your usage, it might swing you closer to Cosy.

Axle is compatible with most Octopus tariffs, with I think just 2 exceptions from memory; intelligent Flux/Go

Battery life is measured in terms of 'Cycles' so from flat to full and flat again. Typically you should get say 6,000 cycles, before you have 70% of the original capacity left (or some such values) Roughly 16 years worth of cycles, and outside of (my) 10 year battery warranty. Capacity is increasing with batteries, and costs are coming down, though the floor might level off at some point. Don't forget, you only need to work the battery harder in the Winter, during Summer, you'll hardly use all the capacity typically.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
I've seen a couple of posts where people have been kicked off Cosy and had the standard tariff retroactively applied to their account. So I'd be a bit cautious.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Hopefully not, but they have been cracking down on things. They have changed the frequent tariff hopping that was going on too I think.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
I've just tried to sign up to Cosy and been refused as I don't have a heat pump or electric boiler.
Solar Panels: Aiko Neostar 3S 475W All Black ABC N-Type Mono × 18
Inverter: Fox ESS KH 7kW 1ph Hybrid Inverter
Battery: Fox ESS EP6 Plus 5.76kWh Li-ion Battery w/ heating function
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
spiral wrote: ↑Tue Nov 17, 2026 3:43 pm I've just tried to sign up to Cosy and been refused as I don't have a heat pump or electric boiler.
What did it fail on?
You may have to tell it a porkie pie that you do have the required item, though risk is upon yourself.
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
I phoned in because I was under a contract but within cooling off period.
I was a bit hasty with my reply above because the person sent me a link because I told them I had one fitted electric radiator (which is true) and they couldn't make the assessment as to whether that qualified. They told me to answer the questions in the link and someone would assess it within a few days. The link had no questions and just signed me up so I am from today on Octopus Cosy. We'll see if they let me stay.
I don't really understand why that tariff is not generally available if someone wants to sign up. Its not costing Octopus and they gain by people moving their usage to the off peak times of the day.
Solar Panels: Aiko Neostar 3S 475W All Black ABC N-Type Mono × 18
Inverter: Fox ESS KH 7kW 1ph Hybrid Inverter
Battery: Fox ESS EP6 Plus 5.76kWh Li-ion Battery w/ heating function
Re: Force charge without my knowledge
Ah, well then fingers crossed. I think just having an oil filled radiator qualifies you etc.
Post Reply